Skip to content
VG Charles & Co

16 November 2026

Why Good Lawyers Sometimes Make the Wrong Career Move

A successful lawyer receives an approach from another firm. The salary is higher, the title is more impressive and the opportunity appears to offer everything that the current role does not.

The conversations go well. The prospective firm is enthusiastic. The lawyers involved seem to share the same ambitions. There is a compelling story about growth, opportunity and the chance to do something different.

Six months later, the enthusiasm has faded. The promised support has not materialised, the anticipated work has been slower to arrive than expected, or the culture is not quite what it appeared to be during the interview process.

The move that looked so attractive on paper has become a source of frustration.

This is not an unusual story. Nor does it necessarily mean that the lawyer or the recruiting firm acted in bad faith. More often, it reflects a failure to examine the right questions before making a significant career decision.

The attraction of the obvious

Senior lawyers are experienced professionals. They assess risk for a living, advise clients on complex decisions and are accustomed to examining the detail behind an attractive proposition.

Yet career decisions can be surprisingly different.

A higher remuneration package can be difficult to ignore. A partnership title may represent recognition that has been a long time coming. A firm expanding into a new market may offer the prospect of building something rather than simply maintaining an established practice.

All of these can be legitimate reasons to move.

The difficulty arises when the visible attractions of an opportunity obscure the questions that will determine whether it succeeds.

What work will the lawyer actually undertake? Which clients are likely to follow? What investment will the firm make in the practice? How will success be measured? Who will be responsible for providing the promised support? And what happens if the business develops more slowly than anticipated?

These are not negative questions. They are the questions that distinguish a well-considered decision from an optimistic assumption.

The difference between a promise and a plan

Law firms recruit senior lawyers because they expect them to contribute something important: clients, revenue, expertise, leadership or access to a market they wish to develop.

The lawyer, in turn, expects the firm to provide an environment in which those contributions can translate into a successful practice.

Both sides may have entirely reasonable expectations. The problem is that they are not always the same expectations.

A firm may believe it has recruited a partner who will generate substantial new business. The partner may believe that the firm will provide the infrastructure, relationships and internal referrals needed to develop that business.

Each side may leave the discussions convinced that the other understands the arrangement.

Unless the assumptions are tested, however, the relationship can begin with two different definitions of success.

Before accepting an offer, a senior lawyer should try to establish which commitments are concrete and which are aspirational. A stated intention to invest in a team is not the same as an agreed recruitment plan. An expectation of internal referrals is not a guarantee of work. A target for future revenue is not evidence that the necessary resources will be available.

The distinction matters because a lateral appointment is rarely successful on the strength of one individual’s ability alone.

The importance of the people around you

A move is often presented as a decision about the firm. In practice, it is also a decision about the people with whom the lawyer will work.

The managing partner may be impressive, but how accessible will that person be after the appointment? Does the leadership team agree on the strategic direction of the practice? Are colleagues likely to collaborate, or will the new arrival be expected to build a business in isolation?

Culture is sometimes dismissed as an intangible consideration. For a senior lawyer, it can be a commercial issue.

The willingness of colleagues to share opportunities, the speed of internal decision-making, the quality of administrative support and the firm’s approach to investment can all influence whether a practice develops successfully.

A candidate should therefore look beyond the people involved in the recruitment process. Where possible, conversations with future colleagues can provide a more rounded picture of how the firm operates.

The objective is not to eliminate uncertainty. No recruitment process can do that. It is to understand the environment into which the lawyer is moving.

When dissatisfaction becomes the driving force

Some career moves are motivated less by the attraction of a new opportunity than by frustration with the existing one.

Perhaps the lawyer feels undervalued. Perhaps a promised promotion has been delayed, the relationship with a colleague has deteriorated, or the firm’s strategic priorities have changed.

Those frustrations may be entirely justified. But they can also make an alternative opportunity appear more attractive than it would otherwise seem.

When the desire to leave becomes overwhelming, there is a risk that the candidate begins to assess the new role primarily by reference to what is wrong with the old one.

A better approach is to separate the two decisions.

First, ask whether the current role remains right for the long term. Then assess the proposed move on its own merits.

A new firm should not be judged solely by its ability to solve the problems of the present. It should offer a credible and sustainable proposition in its own right.

The recruiter’s responsibility

This is where an experienced recruitment adviser should add value.

The role is not simply to introduce a candidate to a firm, negotiate an attractive package and secure an acceptance. Those things may be part of the process, but they do not by themselves constitute a successful appointment.

Good recruitment involves testing expectations on both sides, identifying potential areas of misunderstanding and encouraging difficult conversations before they become expensive problems.

That may mean asking a firm to explain how it intends to support a new partner’s practice. It may mean helping a candidate examine whether the opportunity genuinely fits their ambitions. On occasion, it may mean recognising that a move should not proceed.

That last outcome can be difficult to measure. It does not produce an immediate appointment. But preventing a poorly matched move can be just as valuable as completing a successful one.

The interests of the candidate and the firm are best served when the decision is based on a realistic understanding of the opportunity, rather than enthusiasm alone.

A better set of questions

Before making a senior career move, it is worth stepping back from the headline offer and asking a few straightforward questions:

  • What specifically will make this role successful after 12 and 24 months?

  • Are the expectations of the firm and the candidate genuinely aligned?

  • Which resources, relationships and commitments will be available from the outset?

  • What are the principal risks, and have they been discussed openly?

  • Does the opportunity fit the candidate’s longer-term ambitions, or does it simply solve an immediate frustration?

  • Having met the people and examined the proposition, does the move still make sense if the initial excitement is removed?

None of these questions guarantees success. But they encourage a more disciplined decision.

The right move is the one that remains right

Senior appointments are consequential decisions. They affect income, professional reputation, client relationships, teams and, often, family life.

A move should therefore be judged by more than the quality of the offer or the excitement of a new beginning.

The best career decisions tend to emerge from honest conversations, realistic expectations and a clear understanding of what both sides are committing to.

A prestigious title, an attractive package or an ambitious growth plan may all be compelling. The real test is whether the opportunity will still look compelling when the initial enthusiasm has passed and the work of building a successful practice begins.

The best moves are not necessarily the most dramatic. They are the ones that remain right when the excitement has passed.


The Monday Briefing is VG Charles & Co’s regular exploration of the issues shaping senior legal recruitment, law firm strategy and the people behind important professional decisions.

Tony Tomkins is the founder and MD of VG CHARLES&CO a firm he established after a successful career at the bar. He has been involved in multiple law firm mergers and team moves throughout the UK.

All articles